Factors That Impact Settlement Timelines
Settlement timelines can vary significantly depending on case complexity, insurance company responsiveness, and the completeness of submitted documentation:
- Case Complexity and Policy Limits: More complex cases involving severe injuries, disputed liability, or high policy limits generally take longer to settle. Insurers scrutinize these cases more thoroughly, and negotiations may involve multiple rounds of counteroffers. (Learn more about simplifying caseload management here.)
- Insurance Company Response Patterns: Insurance companies operate on their own timelines, with some taking weeks or even months to review and respond to demands. Industry benchmarks indicate that settlement delays are common when dealing with large insurers that process high claim volumes.
- Demand Package Completeness: One of the most significant factors affecting settlement speed is the completeness of the demand package. Missing documents, such as medical bills, treatment records, and policy limit disclosures, can cause insurers to delay or undervalue claims. According to EvenUp’s 2025 Benchmarks Report, firms miss an average of five documents for every ten cases—resulting in unnecessary settlement delays and lost revenue. (More on this later!)
How to Reduce Settlement Wait Times
By streamlining internal processes and ensuring demand packages are complete and compelling, firms can reduce settlement delays and secure faster resolutions for their clients:
- Submitting Comprehensive, Well-Supported Demands: A complete demand package eliminates the need for insurers to request additional information, reducing delays. Firms that ensure all medical records and supporting documentation are included upfront can cut settlement times by weeks or even months.
- Using AI-Powered Tools to Streamline Demand Drafting: AI-driven legal tools—such as EvenUp’s Case Companion™—automate case file analysis, identify missing records, and ensure demands are persuasive and complete. Missing documents can significantly impact settlement outcomes for law firms; one missing document for every other case may not seem like much, but with each potentially costing $3,000 in lost settlement value, these missing documents deplete your case outcomes and cost your firm money. Law firms that proactively address missing documents can increase settlement values by up to $400,000 per year.
- Avoiding Common Negotiation Pitfalls: Attorneys must proactively follow up with insurance adjusters to keep the settlement process moving. In cases where negotiations stall, escalating the case to litigation can serve as a strategic move to prompt quicker resolutions.
What to Expect After Sending a Demand Letter
Once a demand letter is submitted, insurers will assess the claim, negotiate terms, and determine whether to settle or push the case toward litigation:
- Average Insurer Response Timelines: While some insurers respond within a few weeks, others may take several months, depending on claim volume, internal review processes, and the strength of the demand letter.
- The Role of Follow-Ups in Accelerating Settlements: Consistent follow-ups can prevent insurers from deprioritizing cases. Firms that maintain proactive communication with adjusters often achieve faster settlements than those that take a passive approach.
- When to Escalate to Litigation: If an insurer refuses to negotiate in good faith or offers an unreasonably low settlement, attorneys should consider escalating the case to litigation. This step signals to insurers that the firm is serious about securing a fair settlement for its client.
Maximizing Settlement Speed and Case Outcomes
The simple answer to your client’s question is: “Settlement timelines depend on a variety of factors, but by leveraging legal tech, our firm is expediting your case as strategically as possible.”
Personal injury attorneys can dramatically reduce settlement timelines (and enhance law firm profitability) by leveraging AI-driven tools, submitting complete demand packages, and maintaining proactive negotiation strategies. EvenUp’s Case Companion™ and our Missing Documents Check feature streamline document review and ensure that law firms can quickly identify and rectify gaps that would otherwise slow down settlements.
By implementing these best practices, law firms can expedite settlements and maximize their clients' financial recovery.
To learn more about how EvenUp helps personal injury firms settle faster and for higher amounts, download our 2025 Benchmarks Report today.
.png)
